Posts tagged ·

storage

·...

Storage prices

no comments

If you need massive storage, 6 TB disks are already very competitively priced. However, the 3 TB WD Green still gives the most GB per coin. Amongst SSD, several 1 TB disks rank towards the top, but still at ten times more than magnetic. Finally, USB flash drives and SD cards are coming down in price, with a large 64 GB option at the top.

Details of updates

There has been several announcements of products you cannot buy yet lately. On the following list, all are for sale and immediate delivery.

The list has seen significant updates since last time, in product ranges, prices: Western Digital now has five colour codes for their desktop disks, three of which are included here. There is the inexpensive large but slow Green, the Red for NAS and RAID with extra warranty, and the Purple in between. Also new since February are the 5 and 6 TB disks.

At 92 Euros, the 3 TB Green is at the top of the list at 32.4 GB per Euro. It is interesting to note that the 6 TB version is already towards the top, at just a bit more than double the price; €202, or 29.6 GB/€. For external disks, the 4 TB Elements Desktop is at the top, for €135, or 29 GB/€.

Amongst the SSD disks, the largest are now at the top, with Crucial 1 TB, 512 GB, and Samsung 1 TB all around 3 GB/€. Most interesting, is the fact that the Crucial claim to be MLC while the Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic is a TLC based disk. The Samsung MLC disk are far more expensive, starting below 2 GB/€. It a sign of a very competitive market, and further decrease in prices ahead.

Finally, lower solid state prices also benefit memory cards and USB sticks. The Sandisk Cruzer Edge 64 GB drive now gives most storage for money. A bit further down, the Sandisk Ultra 64 GB and 128 GB SD cards are good large capacity options, although with slow 30 Mb/s read and write speeds. For top write speed, at an impressive 280/250 Mb/s read/write, see the new UHS-II based 64 GB SDXC card.

The List

Media Type Product Capacity Price CHF Price Euros Euros / GB GBs / Euro
HDD Western Digital Green 3TB 3000 GB 112.00 92.56 0.03 32.41
HDD Seagate Desktop 4TB 4000 GB 159.00 131.40 0.03 30.44
HDD Western Digital Green 4TB 4000 GB 161.00 133.06 0.03 30.06
HDD Western Digital Green 6TB 6000 GB 245.00 202.48 0.03 29.63
External 3.5 Western Digital Elements Desktop 4TB, USB3 4000 GB 164.00 135.54 0.03 29.51
HDD Western Digital Purple 3TB 3000 GB 125.00 103.31 0.03 29.04
HDD Western Digital Green 2TB 2000 GB 85.00 70.25 0.04 28.47
HDD Western Digital Red 3TB 3000 GB 130.00 107.44 0.04 27.92
External 3.5 Western Digital Elements Desktop 3TB, USB3 3000 GB 130.00 107.44 0.04 27.92
HDD Western Digital Purple 4TB 4000 GB 175.00 144.63 0.04 27.66
HDD Western Digital Red 4TB 4000 GB 177.00 146.28 0.04 27.34
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book 3TB, USB3 3000 GB 135.00 111.57 0.04 26.89
HDD Western Digital Red 5TB 5000 GB 226.00 186.78 0.04 26.77
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book 4TB, USB3 4000 GB 182.00 150.41 0.04 26.59
HDD Hitachi Deskstar 7K4000, 4TB 4000 GB 184.00 152.07 0.04 26.30
HDD Western Digital Red 6TB 6000 GB 279.00 230.58 0.04 26.02
HDD Western Digital Purple 2TB 2000 GB 95.40 78.84 0.04 25.37
HDD Western Digital Red 2TB 2000 GB 104.00 85.95 0.04 23.27
External 2.5 Western Digital Elements Portable 2TB, USB3 2000 GB 109.00 90.08 0.05 22.20
HDD Western Digital Green 1TB 1000 GB 62.20 51.40 0.05 19.45
External 2.5 Western Digital My Passport Ultra 2TB, USB3 2000 GB 127.00 104.96 0.05 19.06
HDD Western Digital Purple 1TB 1000 GB 69.60 57.52 0.06 17.39
HDD Western Digital Red 1TB 1000 GB 70.50 58.26 0.06 17.16
External 2.5 Western Digital My Passport Ultra 1TB, USB3 1000 GB 75.90 62.73 0.06 15.94
External 2.5 Western Digital Elements Portable 1TB, USB3 1000 GB 77.90 64.38 0.06 15.53
DVD-R Verbatim 16x DVD-R 100 @ 4,7GB 470 GB 40.40 33.39 0.07 14.08
Blu-ray Verbatim BD-R SL 10 @ 25GB 250 GB 25.00 20.66 0.08 12.10
Blu-ray Verbatim BD-R DL 10 @ 50GB 500 GB 57.30 47.36 0.09 10.56
DVD+R DL Verbatim 8x DVD+R DL 50 @ 8,5GB 425 GB 69.10 57.11 0.13 7.44
DVD+R DL Verbatim 8x DVD+R DL 25 @ 8,5GB 213 GB 36.40 30.08 0.14 7.06
SSD Crucial MX100 SSD, MLC, 512GB 512 GB 199.00 164.46 0.32 3.11
SSD Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic, TLC, 1TB 1000 GB 399.00 329.75 0.33 3.03
SSD Crucial M550 SSD, MLC, 1024GB 1024 GB 424.00 350.41 0.34 2.92
SSD Crucial M550 SSD, MLC, 512GB 512 GB 224.00 185.12 0.36 2.77
SSD Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic, TLC, 500GB 500 GB 226.00 186.78 0.37 2.68
SSD Crucial M500 SSD, MLC, 960GB 960 GB 445.00 367.77 0.38 2.61
SSD Crucial M500 SSD, MLC, 480GB 480 GB 237.00 195.87 0.41 2.45
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Edge Flash Drive 64GB 64 GB 33.50 27.69 0.43 2.31
CD-R Verbatim CD-R 100 @ 700MB 70 GB 36.80 30.41 0.43 2.30
SSD Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic, TLC, 750GB 750 GB 404.00 333.88 0.45 2.25
SSD Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic, TLC, 250GB 250 GB 137.00 113.22 0.45 2.21
SSD Samsung SSD 850 Pro, MLC, 1024GB 1024 GB 635.00 524.79 0.51 1.95
SSD Samsung SSD 840 Pro Basic, MLC, 512GB 512 GB 333.00 275.21 0.54 1.86
SSD Samsung SSD 840 Pro Basic, MLC, 256GB 256 GB 167.00 138.02 0.54 1.85
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Edge Flash Drive 32GB 32 GB 21.00 17.36 0.54 1.84
SSD Samsung SSD 850 Pro, MLC, 256GB 256 GB 179.00 147.93 0.58 1.73
SSD Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic, TLC, 120GB 120 GB 84.20 69.59 0.58 1.72
SSD Samsung SSD 850 Pro, MLC, 512GB 512 GB 378.00 312.40 0.61 1.64
SDXC Sandisk Ultra, SDXC, 30MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 52.00 42.98 0.67 1.49
SDXC Sandisk Ultra, SDXC, 30MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 105.00 86.78 0.68 1.48
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Edge Flash Drive 16GB 16 GB 13.30 10.99 0.69 1.46
SSD Samsung SSD 840 Pro Basic, MLC, 128GB 128 GB 112.00 92.56 0.72 1.38
SSD Samsung SSD 850 Pro, MLC, 128GB 128 GB 128.00 105.79 0.83 1.21
SDXC Sandisk Extreme, SDXC, 45MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 65.10 53.80 0.84 1.19
USB Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro, USB 3.0, 128GB 128 GB 135.00 111.57 0.87 1.15
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 35.00 28.93 0.90 1.11
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Edge Flash Drive 8GB 8 GB 8.95 7.40 0.92 1.08
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 18.80 15.54 0.97 1.03
SDXC Sandisk Extreme SDXC, 80/60MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 162.00 133.88 1.05 0.96
SDXC Sandisk Extreme SDXC, 80/60MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 89.00 73.55 1.15 0.87
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 12.30 10.17 1.27 0.79
SDXC Sandisk Extreme Pro SDXC, 90/95MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 117.00 96.69 1.51 0.66
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 78.00 64.46 2.01 0.50
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme 120MB/s, UDMA 7, 64GB 64 GB 167.00 138.02 2.16 0.46
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 160MB/s, UDMA 7, 256GB 256 GB 709.00 585.95 2.29 0.44
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 46.10 38.10 2.38 0.42
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme 120MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 384.00 317.36 2.48 0.40
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme 60MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 228.00 188.43 2.94 0.34
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme 120MB/s, UDMA 7, 32GB 32 GB 116.00 95.87 3.00 0.33
Compact Flash SanDisk Ultra 30MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 58.50 48.35 3.02 0.33
SDXC Sandisk Extreme SDXC, 80/30MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 29.30 24.21 3.03 0.33
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 30.30 25.04 3.13 0.32
SDXC Sandisk Extreme Pro SDXC, UHS-II, 280/250MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 247.00 204.13 3.19 0.31
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 160MB/s, UDMA 7, 32GB 32 GB 149.00 123.14 3.85 0.26
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 160MB/s, UDMA 7, 64GB 64 GB 333.00 275.21 4.30 0.23
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 60MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 84.30 69.67 4.35 0.23
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 160MB/s, UDMA 7, 128GB 128 GB 708.00 585.12 4.57 0.22
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 120MB/s, UDMA 7, 16GB 16 GB 91.00 75.21 4.70 0.21
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 100MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 776.00 641.32 5.01 0.20
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 90MB/s, UDMA 6, 32GB 32 GB 224.00 185.12 5.79 0.17
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 90MB/s, UDMA 6, 64GB 64 GB 452.00 373.55 5.84 0.17

Exchange rate: 1 Euro = 1.210000 CHF.

Why 10TB drives could be bad news

1 comment

In this week’s news, Hitachi GST (HGST) announced a 10 TB HDD. It ups the earlier announcement by Seagate of a 8 TB disk. Although both companies claim the disks are “shipped”, they are nowhere near consumers yet. Both are shipping samples to a select few partners. Tech writers are ecstatic, though, and are happily re-publishing most of the official press release.

10 TB in a 3.5″ HDD is an impressive feat in itself, however the technology used to achieve it might mark the end of general purpose magnetic disks: First, this is another helium based disk from HGST, which stacks seven platters. It remains to be seen how long the helium can be contained within the disk, but is probably a lot shorter than the shelf-life of an air-based magnetic disk. Regardless of lifespan, what makes the 10 TB milestone less impressive, and even slightly worrisome, is the seven platters. That is a one-time trick. We cannot expect disks with even more platters stacked on top of each other in the future, so growth will not continue that route. It has to come from increased areal density of the bits per platter.

The brings me to the second issue with this disk: Areal density is achieved by so called Shingled Magnetic Recording (SMR). As explained by Seagate, it means that each data track is stacked slightly above the other, just like shingles on a roof. To make this work, existing data has to be re-written if something is changed in neighboring tracks. This could result in delays when writing data on an almost full disk. Furthermore, it will require special handling by the OS (in case of the “host managed” 10 TB HGST disk). Implementing that right might not be trivial. SMR based disks are in other words not drop-in replacements for all applications. Although, for scenarios which are write once (or infrequently), and read often, this is not a problem.

Combined, these two technologies will most likely take us to 20 TB and beyond. Assuming the 8 TB Seagate disk used five 1.6 TB platters, a seven platter disk would give 11.2 TB. That is of course the advantage of more platters, it amplifies any advance in areal density. Between five and seven platters, the factor is 1.4, and between four and seven it’s 1.75.

The trend of ever decreasing HDD prices will continue, even though the products might not be for everyone.

Seagate brags about 8 TB disks

Comments Off

It was only a few days ago I mentioned Western Digital’s new 6 TB disks. It seems Seagate got nervous, and are now claiming to “ship” 8 TB disks. However, it is a misleading headline at best: The drives in question are not on sale anywhere, and only special “pre-production prototypes” have been given to few select partners. Furthermore, the initial batches will be aimed at enterprise customers who can afford them. As an early-adopter strategy, that makes sense, but it means you will not get your hands on one any time soon. So, the prediction from a few days ago holds: 8.4 TB is already within reach, with 7 platters * 1.2 TB, but needs special technology like helium filled drives. We will probably not have 8 TB drives before 2015.

The bit-tech article is also very light on technical detail, presumably because Seagate holds their cards close. There is no mentioned on how they have gotten to 8 TB, only that 10 TB might also be within reach soon. The later would be very interesting, since even with 7 platters it means an increase in areal density to 1.4 TB per platter. Or if we assume 5 platters, an impressive 2 TB. That will probably not reach the market before end of 2015, possibly 2016.

Comments Off

6 TB disks, 1.2 TB platters finally here

1 comment

Earlier this week, Anandtech could report that Wester Digital has finally taken the next incremental step in spinning HDD size. The WD Red series will now come in sizes of 5 and 6 TB, as will the Green series. 6 TB is accomplished using 5 platters, which is a new trend for Western Digital. As mentioned earlier, the five-platter technology was acquired from Hitachi, and we now start seeing them in NAS type WD drives. With five platters, it means each has 1.2 TB, which is shy of the 1.25 TB expected this year. It is important, since it means the 5 TB version also contains five platters, of 1 TB each, rather than 4 * 1.25 TB.

As the AnandTech article points out, WD is still using Perpendicular Magnetic Recording (PMR) technology, as in previous drives. It means that the 1.2 TB areal density should be easily compatible with the HGST seven platters helium drives. That should make 7 * 1.2 = 8.4 TB drives immediately possible. However, as marketing seems to be focused on whole integer increments only, expect 7 and 8 TB drives in this combination. That would be in line with the predictions seen here last year.

As for price, the WD Green is not yet announced. For the Red series, 5 TB will be $250, and 6 TB $300, which puts both in at 5 cents per GB. That is 39% more expensive than the cheapest Seagate 3 TB disk in the storage graphs. However, the newest and biggest drives always start at a premium for the early adopters. These new drives will probably mean that the previous step, 4 TB, will rise to the top as the best GB per buck.

Historical Cost of Computer Memory and Storage

Comments Off

I’ve finally gotten around to update the graph and data at hblok.net/storage. Since it has been a while since last time, I thought I would be left with a gap in the data. However, John C. McCallum who collected the original data got my back. I’ve incorporated his newer data points, as well as automated my own collection. Hopefully, it will not go quit so long between updates in the future.
 
 

RAM prices up

 
Due to a fire at the Hynix Fab plants in 2012, RAM prices are significantly up, and still at 2012 prices. Joel Hruska at extremetech.com has an interesting analysis into its effects. In the chart below, he notes that prices doubled after the fire. The latest data I’ve collected show that it’s going in the right direction again. However, as Hruska also points out, the market for desktops is in decline, and laptops, tablets and phones will not need the same memory types.


 
 

HDD / Magnet disk prices go sideways

 
In 2011 flooding in Thailand caused major damage to HDD factories of Western Digital, Samsung, and Toshiba. Prices have almost recovered from that by now, however it means a set-back in the HDD trend by almost three years.

In another article by Joel Hruska, he includes the graph below from Backblaze who plotted real and estimated prices on different HDD types. Although he takes issue with Backblaze’s extrapolation, it did get the significant lag of the trend right.

Furthermore, larger drives have yet to materialize. The 6 TB HGST (owned by Western Digital) Ultrastar He6 has been out for a while. Paul Alcorn at tweaktown.com discussed the details in a review a few months back. The trick is to put a whopping seven platters into the drive (as opposed to the normal three to five). However, to make that work, the drive has to be sealed and filled helium; thus its name. The new technology comes at a higher prices: It retails at Amazon for $476.99, or $0.0794/GB. That’s more than double the Seagate 3TB at $109.99 or $0.0367/GB.

So although the helium technology has a long way to go, it could be the next step for higher capacity drives. At 6 TB over 7 platters, each hold only 857 GB. That is a bit off from the 1 TB platters which have been available for a long time now, and we were “promised” 1.25 TB platters by the end of this year. If the later are compatible with the “7Stac” technology, it could mean 1.25 * 7 = 8.75 TB drives in the future. If pricing also improves, it could be that the magnetic hard disk trend is back onto its 40 year track.

 
 

SSD and flash prices down

 
Flash memory and Solid State Drives have no accidents hampering their growth and price decline. The trend is linear (i.e. on the logarithmic scale) over the last ten years. Larger drives are also gradually becoming available, with SanDisk recently announcing their enterprise 4 TB Optimus MAX SAS, and predicting 8 TB SSDs by next year. In that Computer World article, they’ve included a Gartner graph, seen below, which predicts SSD price parity with HDD by 2017. It’s important to note that they compare enterprise drives here, which live in a completely different world than the cheapest and biggest consumer drives.

For the chart I’m tracking, it is mostly the USB sticks that make it to the top, with the best price / capacity ratio. At this point, it seems that is not because the USB sticks are getting larger, but rather that the smallest ones are getting cheaper. SanDisk is now “giving away” 8 GB drives for less than $3 (although that does not give you free shipping at NewEgg).

 
 

Updated overall graph

Finally, the updated graph. The permanent link is hblok.net/storage
 

(Click for larger image)

Comments Off

Storage prices

Comments Off

The new year has not seen major changes to the prices of spinning disks. However, on the SSD side, there are some interesting news, with Samsung really gearing up. Their 840 EVO and Pro series are now amongst the most affordable and reliable disks on the market.

The EVO series uses TLC memory, which stacks more bits per cell. This increases speed, but decreases reliability. The rule of thumb is 1000 writes for TLC memory, while MLC might be 10 times higher at 10k writes. It means that TLC disks will typically be for low to medium consumer use, while MLC is for higher pro use (as the series name also suggests). This is also reflected in Samsung’s warranty: Three years on the TLC disks, which is good, and an impressive five years on the MLC Pro disks. By comparison, Western Digital’s Red series has three years warranty, while the Green series has only two years.

Also notable is the fact that for the first time price per byte is lower for an SSD disk than a stack of 100 CD-Rs. That is of course because the 100 CD stack has stayed at about 30 Euros for the last six or more years. Never the less, it underlines the fact that 2014 will be the year when decent sized SSDs reach reasonable prices. Upgrading an older laptop with a 500 GB or 750 GB SSD is soon at a point where it makes sense, and will give good return on investment.

Media Type Product Capacity Price CHF Price Euros Euros / GB GBs / Euro
Harddisk Seagate Barracuda 4TB 4000 GB 164.00 134.43 0.03 29.76
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 3TB 3000 GB 125.00 102.46 0.03 29.28
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 4TB 4000 GB 169.00 138.52 0.03 28.88
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 2TB 2000 GB 91.00 74.59 0.04 26.81
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 4TB, USB3 4000 GB 183.00 150.00 0.04 26.67
Harddisk Western Digital Red 4TB 4000 GB 185.00 151.64 0.04 26.38
Harddisk Western Digital Red 3TB 3000 GB 139.00 113.93 0.04 26.33
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 3TB, USB3 3000 GB 143.00 117.21 0.04 25.59
Harddisk Hitachi Deskstar 7K4000, 4TB 4000 GB 191.00 156.56 0.04 25.55
External 2.5 Western Digital Elements Portable 2TB, USB3 2000 GB 119.00 97.54 0.05 20.50
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Black 4TB 4000 GB 260.00 213.11 0.05 18.77
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 1TB 1000 GB 67.00 54.92 0.05 18.21
External 2.5 Western Digital My Passport 2TB, USB3 2000 GB 135.00 110.66 0.06 18.07
External 2.5 Western Digital Elements Portable 1TB, USB3 1000 GB 82.00 67.21 0.07 14.88
Blu-ray Verbatim BD-R SL 25 @ 50GB 1250 GB 238.00 195.08 0.16 6.41
DVD+R DL Verbatim 8x DVD+R DL 25 @ 8,5GB 213 GB 42.00 34.43 0.16 6.17
DVD-R Verbatim 16x DVD-R 100 @ 4,7GB 470 GB 96.00 78.69 0.17 5.97
DVD+R DL Verbatim 8x DVD+R DL 10 @ 8,5GB 85 GB 36.00 29.51 0.35 2.88
SSD Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic, TLC, 750GB 750 GB 339.00 277.87 0.37 2.70
CD-R Verbatim CD-R 100 @ 700MB 70 GB 35.00 28.69 0.41 2.44
SSD Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic, TLC, 1TB 1000 GB 555.00 454.92 0.45 2.20
SSD Crucial M500 SSD, MLC, 120GB 120 GB 78.00 63.93 0.53 1.88
SSD Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic, TLC, 500GB 500 GB 329.00 269.67 0.54 1.85
SSD Sandisk Ultra Plus, MLC, 256GB 256 GB 172.00 140.98 0.55 1.82
SSD Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic, TLC, 250GB 250 GB 171.00 140.16 0.56 1.78
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Flash Drive 32GB 32 GB 23.00 18.85 0.59 1.70
SSD Kingston HyperX 3K, MLC, 240GB 240 GB 186.00 152.46 0.64 1.57
SSD Samsung SSD 840 EVO Basic, TLC, 120GB 120 GB 99.00 81.15 0.68 1.48
SSD Samsung SSD 840 Pro Basic, MLC, 512GB 512 GB 439.00 359.84 0.70 1.42
SSD Samsung SSD 840 Pro Basic, MLC, 256GB 256 GB 229.00 187.70 0.73 1.36
SSD Kingston SSDNow KC300, MLC, 120GB 120 GB 111.00 90.98 0.76 1.32
SSD Corsair Force GT, MLC, 240GB 240 GB 222.00 181.97 0.76 1.32
SSD Sandisk Extreme, MLC, 480GB 480 GB 457.00 374.59 0.78 1.28
SSD Corsair Neutron, MLC, 128GB 128 GB 129.00 105.74 0.83 1.21
SDXC Sandisk Ultra SDXC, Class 10, 15/30MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 67.00 54.92 0.86 1.17
SSD Corsair Force GT, MLC, 120GB 120 GB 126.00 103.28 0.86 1.16
SSD Samsung SSD 840 Pro Basic, MLC, 128GB 128 GB 139.00 113.93 0.89 1.12
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Flash Drive 16GB 16 GB 18.00 14.75 0.92 1.08
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 15/30MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 37.00 30.33 0.95 1.06
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Extreme 64GB 64 GB 97.00 79.51 1.24 0.80
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 27.00 22.13 1.38 0.72
SDXC Sandisk Extreme SDXC, UHS-I, 80/60MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 119.00 97.54 1.52 0.66
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 16.00 13.11 1.64 0.61
SDHC Sandisk Extreme, Class 10, 30MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 35.00 28.69 1.79 0.56
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Flash Drive 8GB 8 GB 18.00 14.75 1.84 0.54
SDXC Sandisk Extreme Pro SDXC, UHS-I, 95/45MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 148.00 121.31 1.90 0.53
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class 10, 90/95MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 78.00 63.93 2.00 0.50
Compact Flash SanDisk Ultra 200x, 16GB 16 GB 49.00 40.16 2.51 0.40
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme 800x, 120MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 426.00 349.18 2.73 0.37
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 27.00 22.13 2.77 0.36
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 55.00 45.08 2.82 0.35
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme 800x, 120MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 230.00 188.52 2.95 0.34
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 123.00 100.82 3.15 0.32
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 160MB/s, 256GB 256 GB 1306.00 1070.49 4.18 0.24
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 600x, 90MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 126.00 103.28 6.45 0.15

Exchange rate: 1 Euro = 1.220000 CHF.

Comments Off

Storage prices

Comments Off

4 TB is finally at the top now, giving most storage for money. Both the Western Digital and Seagate drives are priced at 144 Euros, making them the new ideal disk for a large storage or backup systems. Furthermore, WD has put out a 4 TB in their My Book external series, which again gives more bytes per coin than its 3 TB little brother.

On the Sandisk Compact Flash end of the list there are also some interesting additions. They have added new Extreme Pro editions, at 120 MB/s and at a really extreme 160 MB/s read/write speed. On their own marketing page, they claim these cards are suited for shooting “4K” (e.g. 3840 × 2160 or 4096 × 2160). However, these cards are expensive, at 630 Euros for 128 GB, and 1200 Euros for 256 GB; not for the hobbyist in other words.

Media Type Product Capacity Price CHF Price Euros Euros / GB GBs / Euro
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 4TB 4000 GB 179.00 144.35 0.04 27.71
Harddisk Seagate Barracuda 4TB 4000 GB 179.00 144.35 0.04 27.71
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 3TB 3000 GB 135.00 108.87 0.04 27.56
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 4TB, USB3 4000 GB 184.00 148.39 0.04 26.96
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 3TB, USB3 3000 GB 143.00 115.32 0.04 26.01
Harddisk Western Digital Red 3TB 3000 GB 145.00 116.94 0.04 25.66
Harddisk Western Digital Red 4TB 4000 GB 199.00 160.48 0.04 24.92
Harddisk Hitachi Deskstar 7K4000, 4TB 4000 GB 199.00 160.48 0.04 24.92
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 2TB 2000 GB 107.00 86.29 0.04 23.18
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Black 4TB 4000 GB 264.00 212.90 0.05 18.79
External 2.5 Western Digital Elements Portable 2TB, USB3 2000 GB 137.00 110.48 0.06 18.10
External 2.5 Western Digital My Passport 2TB, USB3 2000 GB 139.00 112.10 0.06 17.84
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 1TB 1000 GB 70.00 56.45 0.06 17.71
External 2.5 Western Digital Elements Portable 1TB, USB3 1000 GB 83.00 66.94 0.07 14.94
External 2.5 Western Digital My Passport 1TB, USB3 1000 GB 84.00 67.74 0.07 14.76
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 1TB, USB3 1000 GB 105.00 84.68 0.08 11.81
Blu-ray Verbatim BD-R SL 25 @ 50GB 1250 GB 238.00 191.94 0.15 6.51
DVD+R DL Verbatim 8x DVD+R DL 25 @ 8,5GB 213 GB 42.00 33.87 0.16 6.27
DVD-R Verbatim 16x DVD-R 100 @ 4,7GB 470 GB 96.00 77.42 0.16 6.07
DVD+R DL Verbatim 8x DVD+R DL 10 @ 8,5GB 85 GB 36.00 29.03 0.34 2.93
CD-R Verbatim CD-R 100 @ 700MB 70 GB 35.00 28.23 0.40 2.48
SSD Samsung SSD 840 Basic, TLC, 500GB 500 GB 333.00 268.55 0.54 1.86
SSD Sandisk Extreme 480GB 480 GB 339.00 273.39 0.57 1.76
SSD Corsair Neutron 256GB 256 GB 207.00 166.94 0.65 1.53
SSD Corsair Force GT 240GB 240 GB 225.00 181.45 0.76 1.32
SSD Corsair Neutron 128GB 128 GB 123.00 99.19 0.77 1.29
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Flash Drive 32GB 32 GB 31.00 25.00 0.78 1.28
SSD Corsair Force GT 120GB 120 GB 128.00 103.23 0.86 1.16
SDXC Sandisk Ultra SDXC, Class 10, 15/30MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 75.00 60.48 0.95 1.06
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Flash Drive 16GB 16 GB 19.00 15.32 0.96 1.04
USB Flash Sandisk Ultra Cruzer BACKUP 64GB 64 GB 77.00 62.10 0.97 1.03
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 15/30MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 41.00 33.06 1.03 0.97
SDXC Sandisk Extreme SDXC, UHS-I, 45MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 208.00 167.74 1.31 0.76
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Blade 8GB 8 GB 13.00 10.48 1.31 0.76
SDXC Sandisk Extreme SDXC, UHS-I, 80/60MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 115.00 92.74 1.45 0.69
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 29.00 23.39 1.46 0.68
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 18.00 14.52 1.81 0.55
SDXC Sandisk Extreme Pro SDXC, UHS-I, 95/45MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 148.00 119.35 1.86 0.54
SDHC Sandisk Extreme, Class 10, 30MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 38.00 30.65 1.92 0.52
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class 10, 90/95MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 78.00 62.90 1.97 0.51
SDHC Sandisk Extreme, Class 10, 30MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 21.00 16.94 2.12 0.47
Compact Flash SanDisk Ultra 200x, 16GB 16 GB 50.00 40.32 2.52 0.40
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 200.00 161.29 2.52 0.40
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 27.00 21.77 2.72 0.37
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 55.00 44.35 2.77 0.36
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 112.00 90.32 2.82 0.35
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme 800x, 120MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 457.00 368.55 2.88 0.35
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme 800x, 120MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 230.00 185.48 2.90 0.35
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 160MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 365.00 294.35 4.60 0.22
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 160MB/s, 256GB 256 GB 1479.00 1192.74 4.66 0.21
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 600x, 90MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 191.00 154.03 4.81 0.21
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 48.00 38.71 4.84 0.21
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 98.00 79.03 4.94 0.20
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 160MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 786.00 633.87 4.95 0.20
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 600x, 90MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 102.00 82.26 5.14 0.19

Exchange rate: 1 Euro = 1.240000 CHF.

Comments Off

Storage prices

Comments Off

The wobbly economy seems to have stalled the improvements in prices seen at the beginning of the year, and certain SSD and memory offerings are now slightly more expensive than in February. Spinning disks have declined a bit, but we will probably have to wait till the end of the year, when the new 5 TB disks come online, to see significant shifts.

On the bright side, 4 TB disks are now really taking off, with the Seagate Barracuda 4 TB now just marginally more expensive than the WD Green 3 TB in terms of bucks per GB. Also interesting, is the WD Red offering, which at only 10 Euros difference to the Green 3 TB counterpart now looks like a very good deal. The difference is the manufacturer warranty at 3 vs. 2/1 years, but also in number of platters, 3 for the former, while Green is still on 4 x 750 GB (as far as I know). Since my old HD is shown critical signs of ageing, I might just pick up one of those.

Finally, I’ve also updated the long term history chart at hblok.net/storage. Again, somewhat sideways movement for some of the items.

Media Type Product Capacity Price CHF Price Euros Euros / GB GBs / Euro
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 3TB 3000 GB 137.00 111.38 0.04 26.93
Harddisk Seagate Barracuda 4TB 4000 GB 185.00 150.41 0.04 26.59
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 3TB, USB3 3000 GB 144.00 117.07 0.04 25.63
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 4TB, USB3 4000 GB 195.00 158.54 0.04 25.23
Harddisk Western Digital Red 3TB 3000 GB 149.00 121.14 0.04 24.77
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 2TB 2000 GB 105.00 85.37 0.04 23.43
Harddisk Hitachi Deskstar 7K4000, 4TB 4000 GB 229.00 186.18 0.05 21.48
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 2TB, USB3 2000 GB 115.00 93.50 0.05 21.39
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Black 4TB 4000 GB 284.00 230.89 0.06 17.32
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 1TB 1000 GB 72.00 58.54 0.06 17.08
External 2.5 Western Digital My Passport 2TB, USB3 2000 GB 149.00 121.14 0.06 16.51
Harddisk Western Digital RE 4TB 4000 GB 368.00 299.19 0.07 13.37
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 1TB, USB3 1000 GB 105.00 85.37 0.09 11.71
Blu-ray Verbatim BD-R SL 25 @ 50GB 1250 GB 238.00 193.50 0.15 6.46
DVD+R DL Verbatim 8x DVD+R DL 25 @ 8,5GB 213 GB 42.00 34.15 0.16 6.22
DVD-R Verbatim 16x DVD-R 100 @ 4,7GB 470 GB 96.00 78.05 0.17 6.02
DVD+R DL Verbatim 8x DVD+R DL 10 @ 8,5GB 85 GB 36.00 29.27 0.34 2.90
CD-R Verbatim CD-R 100 @ 700MB 70 GB 35.00 28.46 0.41 2.46
SSD Samsung SSD 840 Basic, TLC, 500GB 500 GB 329.00 267.48 0.53 1.87
SSD Corsair Neutron 256GB 256 GB 212.00 172.36 0.67 1.49
SSD Sandisk Extreme 480GB 480 GB 400.00 325.20 0.68 1.48
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Flash Drive 32GB 32 GB 29.00 23.58 0.74 1.36
SSD Corsair Force GT 240GB 240 GB 224.00 182.11 0.76 1.32
SSD Corsair Neutron 128GB 128 GB 125.00 101.63 0.79 1.26
SSD OCZ Agility 3 120GB 120 GB 119.00 96.75 0.81 1.24
SSD OCZ Vertex 3 240GB 240 GB 239.00 194.31 0.81 1.24
SSD OCZ Vertex 4 128GB 128 GB 136.00 110.57 0.86 1.16
SSD Corsair Force GT 120GB 120 GB 131.00 106.50 0.89 1.13
USB Flash Sandisk Ultra Cruzer BACKUP 64GB 64 GB 70.00 56.91 0.89 1.12
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Flash Drive 16GB 16 GB 19.00 15.45 0.97 1.04
SDXC Sandisk Ultra SDXC, Class 10, 15/30MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 78.00 63.41 0.99 1.01
SDXC Sandisk Extreme SDXC, UHS-I, 45MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 168.00 136.59 1.07 0.94
SSD OCZ Agility 3 240GB 240 GB 322.00 261.79 1.09 0.92
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 15/30MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 43.00 34.96 1.09 0.92
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Blade 8GB 8 GB 13.00 10.57 1.32 0.76
SDXC Sandisk Extreme SDXC, UHS-I, 45MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 114.00 92.68 1.45 0.69
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 29.00 23.58 1.47 0.68
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 16.00 13.01 1.63 0.61
SDHC Sandisk Extreme, Class 10, 30MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 35.00 28.46 1.78 0.56
SDHC Sandisk Extreme, Class 10, 30MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 18.00 14.63 1.83 0.55
SDXC Sandisk Extreme Pro SDXC, UHS-I, 95/45MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 148.00 120.33 1.88 0.53
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class 10, 90/95MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 78.00 63.41 1.98 0.50
Compact Flash SanDisk Ultra 200x, 16GB 16 GB 50.00 40.65 2.54 0.39
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 200.00 162.60 2.54 0.39
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 102.00 82.93 2.59 0.39
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 27.00 21.95 2.74 0.36
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 55.00 44.72 2.79 0.36
SDHC Sandisk Extreme, Class 6, 20MB/s, 4GB 4 GB 17.00 13.82 3.46 0.29
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 600x, 90MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 329.00 267.48 4.18 0.24
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 100MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 659.00 535.77 4.19 0.24
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 600x, 90MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 174.00 141.46 4.42 0.23
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 89.00 72.36 4.52 0.22
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 47.00 38.21 4.78 0.21
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 600x, 90MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 103.00 83.74 5.23 0.19

Exchange rate: 1 Euro = 1.230000 CHF.

Comments Off

Concerns about SSD reliability debunked (again)

Comments Off

Background

The myths about how you should use an SSD, and what you should not do with it keep on spinning. Even if there are frequent articles which crunch the actual numbers, the superstition persists. Back in 2008, Robert Penz concluded that your 64 GB SSD could be used for swap, a journalling file system, and consumer level logging, and still last between 20 and 50 years under extreme use.

Fast forward to 2013, with 120 and 240 GB drives becoming affordable, the problem should have virtually disappeared from consumer grade hardware, but people are still worried. So when Magnus Deininger did some estimates on SSD stress testing, he got flack from Slashdot since he did not cover the consumer level disks. The write endurance and number of estimated write cycles on a single block before it goes bad varies widely between consumer and enterprise grade disks, ranging from only 1000 cycles to a million. This article from Centon explains why that is. As can be seen from the simplified figure below, the cheaper consumer drives using “TLC” (Three Layer Cell) or “MLC” (Multi Layer Cell) memory cram the data a lot closer, and thus degrade quicker than enterprise grade “SLC” (Single Layer Cell) memory.

Stress test of consumer SSD

Deininger concerned himself only with the high end drives, with 100k to 1M write cycles, while most folks over at Slashdot seems to have the low end ones, at 1k – 10k write cycles, and thus the furore. However, Deininger’s estimates were also skewed against the high end drives, since he used the maximum write speed of the SATA 3 controller, which at 6 Gbit/s (750 MByte/s) is lot more than the ~500 MB/s a typical SSD is rated for, or the ~250 MB/s you probably get out of it on a consumer system. And even that is still estimates for a stress tests, and does not even start to model a typical consumer usage pattern.

Deininger goes into detail on how he came up with the estimates, and also how to plot his graphs in Gnuplot. So based on that, let’s run a few numbers, covering the 10k and 1k disks and typical use. However, let’s first drop the stress test write speed down from max controller speed to typical system speed of 250 MB/s. Also, for his plots, he uses multiples of 1024, which for flash memory based drives might be correct, but is not universally used; for example Intel specifies in GB (base 10), while OCZ in GiB (base 2). For transfer speed, this is wrong, as base 10 is the norm. Although it does not make a big difference, I’ve changed to base 10 numbers.

The graphs show time on the x-axis (days on the two first, and years in the next section), and the fraction of broken memory cells (or blocks) on the y-axis. That is, from 0 damaged cells, to 100% or all of them at the top. A horizontal lines marks the 10% point in all graphs since this is usually the point where damaged cells will be visible to the end user. Before that, the internal write levelling on the disk controller will hide these cells, since most disks come with about 10% space reserved for this. (Thus a disk with 128 GiB space is sold as 120 GB, and 256 GiB is sold as 240 GB).

First, there are a few fundamentals based on Deininger equations which can be seen in his examples, and also becomes clear in the graphs above: Doubling storage capacity of the drive doubles the time to failure (at the 10% line). And increasing flash lifespan by a factor of ten also increases time to failure by a factor of ten. All linear relationships, and no magic there, in other words.

For the three drive sizes considered (I dropped the 32 GB size, as I did not find it worthwhile for almost any application any more), the failure times at 10.000 write cycles are 26, 51, and 103 days for 64, 128 and 256 GB respectively. For TLC memory, at only 1000 cycles, the times are thus also a tenth; 2.6, 5.1 and 10.3 days.

If you were to conduct a stress test of drives from different manufactures, these numbers would be interesting. You could for example do the write, check and remove operations continuously till you start to see errors on the data written. However, as read speeds are typically around the same as write speeds for most SSDs, it would actually take at least twice as long as the points in these graphs. (The remove operation also has to be factored in, but is only a fraction of full read and write).

Typical usage

For any performance test it is important to understand where the critical failure points are. However, it does still not tell us what will happen on a typical home user system. A typical consumer would not fill up his whole drive multiple times a day, only to remove it all and start over. So how best to simulate typical user behaviour. Well, we could of course just leave the drive in a machine, and run user software over many years to see what happens. That would not be practical, as we’d never get any useful results in a reasonable time. So, we’re left with estimates, but at a different write speed than the stress test above.

How much would a typical user write to his disk? There will be different use cases of course, but let’s assume two scenarios: a low to medium use case, where 1 GB is written every day, and a heavy home user who writes 1 GB an hour, every day (although, even that is probably beyond what could be labelled as consumer usage). At this point, a table of the different speeds and units comes in handy, so we can wrap our head around the numbers. It then becomes clear how extreme the 250 MB/s stress test actually is, as it will fill up a 64 GB disk 337 times over in 24 hours (250 MB/s * (24*60*60) second = 21600 GB. And 21600 / 64 GB = 337.5 times).

MBit/s MByte/s MByte/hour GByte/day GByte/year
SATA3 max speed 6000 750 2700000 64800 23652000
Stress test 2000 250 900000 21600 7884000
Heavy use 2.2222 0.2778 1000 24 8760
Low/Medium use 0.0926 0.0116 41.67 1 365

Now for some graphs. You’ll have to watch them carefully as the plotted lines are all the same, the y-axis are all the same, the disk sizes are the same, and the only parameters changing are write speed; 1 GB vs. 24 GB a day, and cell cycle life span; 10k vs. 1k. And watch out for the x-axis which are now in years, instead of days above. The first graph shows 10k write cycle disks, where 1 GB is written every day. The smallest disk, at 64 GB, will then last for 1524 years!

Can that be right, you ask? There must be some a mistake in the numbers somewhere? Well, let’s do a quick check to see if it matches Deininger’s graphs: First, his plots were in days, so 1524 years makes 1524 * 365 = 556260 days. Next, the ratio between 6 GBit/s and 1 GByte / day we get from the table above: 64800 (GB / day). Finally, In his first graph, he considered 100k write cycle disks, so we multiply by a factor of 10. Plug in the numbers: 556260 / 64800 * 10 = 86. Exactly matching 86 days for the 64 GB disk at 100k cycles in his first graph. The math works out.

Even in the most unrealistic use case, where a 64 GB drive rated for 1000 write cycles (TLC memory) is filled up almost three times per week, it will last more than six years before the first dead memory cells are likely to show. Moving to a MLC based drive at 10k (still consumer grade), the time to failure moves to 63 years, most likely far outlasting the system it was hosted in, or maybe even the consumer who bought it.

(For the Gnuplot scripts to generate all the graphs above, please see this file).

Conclusion

So will Sold State Drives last till the end of time? Of course not! In fact, plenty of other components are prone to fail just the same way as in old HDDs: Capacitors are infamous for their short lifespan; solder joins might crack. The important point is, it is not the memory cells which are likely to fail first, even under the most extreme use.

Still, it makes sense to deploy tools fit for purpose: An enterprise drive drive using SLC memory, with 100k or 1M write cycles will leave all doubts behind. There will be no need to consider special use cases or take special precautions (beyond normal backup and security procedures which should be in place regardless of drive type). For the home user, the same is true: Even the smallest drives with shortest cell lifespan will not fail under normal use.

More specifically, there are no problems or worries with

  • using ext3, ext4 or other journalling file systems on an SSD.
  • storing /tmp or logs on the SSD.
  • using an SSD partition for memory swap.
  • any normal consumer usage pattern.

In summary: Exchanging the old spinning disk with solid state will pose no extra risk of data loss. It will of course not reduce the risk of loss from other threats either, so normal backup and security procedures should always be in place.

Comments Off

Historical Cost of Computer Memory and Storage

1 comment

Computer storage, primary and secondary memory, has seen a tremendous phase of development over the last fifty years. As new technology has been brought to the market prices have continued to decline steadily at a logarithmic scale. For magnetic storage, the trend has been very stable over the last thirty years, with prices per MB going down around a third every year, or a ninety percent every five years. For primary storage, the trend has been more volatile, but overall we see a similar rate of decline all the way back to the first flip-flops in the 1950s.

John C. McCallum has done a good job collecting all the data over the years, and going back to computer magazines for reference. However, since the beginning of 2012 there have been no updates, so I’ve taken up the work where he left off. I’ve added a new page to my site, where I will collect the data and update the graphs over time: hblok.net/storage


(Click image for larger version)

In the first update, the harddisk prices are most interesting, and we can now clearly see the effect of the flood disaster in late 2011. It has interrupted a thirty year trend, and as a result prices are about the same per MB as they were one and a half years ago. Now the question is, will this have a lasting effect on the magnetic harddisk prices, or will it be just a blip in history, as technological improvements bring us cheaper storage at the same phase.

The two plots below extrapolate the trend over the last thirty years, with two different scenarios: 1) Improvements in technology will catch up with the delay over the last year, and thus the thirty year trend will continue unaffected (red line). Or 2) phase of improvments will not change, and thus the rate of decline in price will stay the same, but shift the line by about a year (blue line).


(Click image for larger version)

The price is 4 cents per GB today (4e-5 per MB). If we look two years ahead, with the uninterrupted scenario (red line), the price would be 0.5 cents per GB in 2015 (5e-6 per MB), or put in different ways: 3 TB of storage which costs $125 today would have to go down to about $15 in two years, or for the same $125 you’d have to get a whopping 25 TB (yes, twenty five!). Given the recent news from the major harddisk vendors, that seems rather unlikely to happen; they’re only planning for 5 TB drives at the end of this year. So, over two years time, prices will not catch up. Perhaps this will change looking even further ahead, however, extrapolating technological trends beyond a year or two is merely guessing.

If we look at the second scenario, where we assume that the prices will continue to decline at the same rate as they have done in the past, given today’s price we’re then looking at about 1.5 cents per GB (1.6e-5 per MB). That would mean that today’s 3 TB would go for around $50, while $125 would buy you about 8 TB. That seems more reasonable, and also in line with what products are being brought to market and in research right now. If the rumoured 5 TB Western Digital disk will be realised with four platters (4 * 1.25 TB) at the end of this year, it means five platter 6.25 TB (5 * 1.25) disks are already a possibility. Increasing storage density another 30% to reach 8 TB over the following year seems a reasonable assumption.

Edit: A previous version of this article placed the decimal point for price per GB incorrectly, at 0.4 cents rather than 4 (although the other numbers were unchanged, as were the extrapolated predictions).

5 TB disks are (almost) here – why duopolies are bad for you

Comments Off

I’m a bit late to the leaked news about the 5 TB Western Digital drives in the beginning of December 2012, however in my defence, I got bored of searching for “4 TB” and “5 TB harddisk” all the time. What’s interesting though, is that according to the leaked documents, 5 TB is nowhere near yet. We’ll have to wait till the end of this year. From the Samsung/Seagate camp I still find nothing.

As mentioned earlier, a 4 TB five platter (5 x 800 GB) was released in the WD enterprise class line, while a 3 TB three platter (3 x 1 TB) came out in the Red series last autumn. This should have made 4 TB four platter and 5 TB five platter disks the next logical conclusion, but for some reason we’ll have to wait another year. With only a single competitor in sight, which doesn’t even have an offering, it is hard to not blame the harddisk duopoly for the lack of progress.

Maybe the most interesting part of this news is that some sites have started to speculate in 1.25 TB platters. That is; would a 5 TB drive use five 1 TB or four 1.25 TB platters. According to xbitlabs, the five platter technology comes from Hitachi, which might explain why we have not seen it in a WD drive before. However, now that they have merged (or acquired), that is a possibility. As far as I can tell, 1.25 TB platters are still under development, but when they come out, the potential is for a 6.25 TB (5 x 1.25) drive. Let’s hope we will not have to wait yet another year for that to happen.

Comments Off

Storage Prices

1 comment

As Geoff Gasior pointed out in Tech Report last month, 3.5″ HDD prices are still significantly higher than pre-flod last year. Interestingly, some of the 2.5″ drivers are cheaper than last year, while some of the smaller 3.5″ drivers are up to 60% more expensive. Couch critics explain it with lack of demand, and HDD companies still recovering their loses from last year.

Despite this lag in price reductions, or perhaps due to the prevailing high prices of 2TB drives, both the WD Green 3 TB (internal and external) drives are now on top of the list. This is a first, and has been a long time coming. It is not much, but you now get 2.7% more bytes for your Euros on a 3TB drive, compared to 2TB internal.

Also interesting in this round, is that Western Digital has finally gotten around to release a 4 TB drive, more than a year after Hitachi showed off their Deskstar 7K4000 4 TB. What’s surprising about WD’s offering, is that this is, like the Deskstar, a five platter (5 x 800GB) drive. Surprising, since WD is already offering 1 TB platters in their Red line, but with max capacity of 3 TB. As discussed earlier, the 4 and 5 TB 1TB/platter drives are highly overdue. What’s more, WD has chosen to introduce the 4TB drives at the top of the range, in its RE 24/7 support, and Black lines. In terms of speed, it does makes sense use more platters in those high-end drives, however, they might also be less reliable, due to more moving parts. Five years factory warranty on the former line does mean they are serious about quality, though.

Finally, as a first, I have included Sandisk’s line of high-end SDHC cards. This is mostly with Raspberry Pi. It is tested and works on most SD cards, but performance might vary.

Media Type Product Capacity Price CHF Price Euros Euros / GB GBs / Euro
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 3TB 3000 GB 159.00 131.62 0.04 22.79
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 3TB, USB3 3000 GB 159.00 131.62 0.04 22.79
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 2TB 2000 GB 109.00 90.23 0.05 22.17
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 2TB, USB3 2000 GB 135.00 111.75 0.06 17.90
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Black 4TB 4000 GB 322.00 266.56 0.07 15.01
Harddisk Hitachi Deskstar 7K4000, 4TB 4000 GB 329.00 272.35 0.07 14.69
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 1TB 1000 GB 84.00 69.54 0.07 14.38
External 2.5 Western Digital My Passport 2TB, USB3 2000 GB 179.00 148.18 0.07 13.50
External 3.5 Western Digital My Book Essential Edition 1TB, USB3 1000 GB 105.00 86.92 0.09 11.50
Harddisk Western Digital RE 4TB 4000 GB 449.00 371.69 0.09 10.76
Harddisk Western Digital Caviar Green 500GB 500 GB 79.00 65.40 0.13 7.65
Blu-ray Verbatim BD-R SL 25 @ 50GB 1250 GB 238.00 197.02 0.16 6.34
DVD+R DL Verbatim 8x DVD+R DL 25 @ 8,5GB 213 GB 42.00 34.77 0.16 6.11
DVD-R Verbatim 16x DVD-R 100 @ 4,7GB 470 GB 96.00 79.47 0.17 5.91
CD-R Verbatim CD-R 100 @ 700MB 70 GB 35.00 28.97 0.41 2.42
SSD OCZ Agility 3 240GB 240 GB 169.00 139.90 0.58 1.72
SSD Corsair Force GT 240GB 240 GB 216.00 178.81 0.75 1.34
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Flash Drive 32GB 32 GB 29.00 24.01 0.75 1.33
SSD OCZ Vertex 3 120GB 120 GB 109.00 90.23 0.75 1.33
SSD Corsair Force3 240GB 240 GB 220.00 182.12 0.76 1.32
SSD OCZ Vertex 3 240GB 240 GB 229.00 189.57 0.79 1.27
SSD Corsair Force GT 120GB 120 GB 121.00 100.17 0.83 1.20
SSD OCZ Agility 3 120GB 120 GB 122.00 100.99 0.84 1.19
SSD Corsair Force3 120GB 120 GB 126.00 104.30 0.87 1.15
USB Flash Sandisk Ultra Cruzer BACKUP 64GB 64 GB 75.00 62.09 0.97 1.03
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 15/30MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 44.00 36.42 1.14 0.88
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Flash Drive 8GB 8 GB 13.00 10.76 1.35 0.74
USB Flash Sandisk Cruzer Flash Drive 16GB 16 GB 26.00 21.52 1.35 0.74
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 27.00 22.35 1.40 0.72
SDHC Sandisk Extreme, Class 10, 30MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 32.00 26.49 1.66 0.60
SDHC Sandisk Extreme, Class 10, 30MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 19.00 15.73 1.97 0.51
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class 10, 90/95MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 84.00 69.54 2.17 0.46
SDHC Sandisk Ultra, Class 10, 30MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 22.00 18.21 2.28 0.44
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 52.00 43.05 2.69 0.37
SDHC Sandisk Extreme Pro, Class UHS-I, 90/95MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 28.00 23.18 2.90 0.35
Compact Flash SanDisk Ultra 200x, 16GB 16 GB 59.00 48.84 3.05 0.33
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 121.00 100.17 3.13 0.32
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 246.00 203.64 3.18 0.31
SDHC Sandisk Extreme, Class 6, 20MB/s, 4GB 4 GB 18.00 14.90 3.73 0.27
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 85.00 70.36 4.40 0.23
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 100MB/s, 128GB 128 GB 819.00 677.98 5.30 0.19
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 600x, 90MB/s, 64GB 64 GB 433.00 358.44 5.60 0.18
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 600x, 90MB/s, 32GB 32 GB 218.00 180.46 5.64 0.18
Compact Flash SanDisk Extreme 400x, 60MB/s, 8GB 8 GB 55.00 45.53 5.69 0.18
Compact Flash Sandisk Extreme Pro 600x, 90MB/s, 16GB 16 GB 131.00 108.44 6.78 0.15

Exchange rate: 1 Euro = 1.208000 CHF.

Where are the 4 and 5 TB drives?

2 comments

The Hitachi Deskstar 7K4000 4 TB is turning one year soon, and since then there have been many interesting events in the harddisk market. Still in memory and felt in the prices is the Thai flood from last autumn; although the prices are finally starting to move back to pre-flood. Then the consolidation of Hitachi into Western Digital, and Samsung into Seagate, leaving only two major HDD manufactures standing.

Since then, there haven’t been to much interesting news, but maybe there are changes on the horizon. WD recently released a new line “WD Red”, targeting the NAS market specifically. See storagereview.com’s review for details. What’s notable is not the line itself, but its internal composition: It’s a 3 TB drive, but using 3 x 1 TB platters, whereas the Green line, at least initially had 4 x 750 GB platters. I am assuming that is still the case.

Four platters is the typical configuration for most high capacity, non-enterprise drives. It is possible to push in five platters, which Seagate has done previously, but four seems to be a good trade-off between reliability and size. As far as I’m aware, WD has not ventured into five platter designs before.

However, now that they have a line using 1 TB platters, why not take the next logical step and offer a 4 TB Green drive? And if Seagate is willing to do a five platter drive again, why not make a 5 TB drive? What is stopping both from taking the next step? Possibly, they are still licking their wounds after the flood? Maybe milking the market for the demand for current capacity drives before moving on? Either way, if we don’t see new 4 and 5 TB headlines by the end of the year, something is really off on the HDD front.

SSD prices declining, but still expensive

1 comment

A recent Guardian article has a small round-up of the latest SSD prices, claiming “SSD prices have halved in a year”. It includes some price points over the last year to back that up, and points out that many offerings have now come down below $1 / GB. This makes SSD drives ideal for boot-up / OS drives, especially in laptops without heavy storage requirements. Indeed, certain laptops are now sold only in SSD configurations.

But is this enough to leave magnetic storage in the dust? No, not so fast. Although some of the commenters concern themselves with the reliability of SSD, this has been debunked a long time ago. Short summary: on a normal user system, you don’t need to take special consideration when switching from spinning to solid drives.

Rather, the price per GB is still an issue. As already mentioned, SSD is dropping fast, but it is still at a 10:1 ratio to magnetic. And even with the hit Western Digital and Seagate took last year, they will continue to innovate. The Hitachi (now owned by WD) Deskstar 7K4000, 4 TB is soon one year old. It features 1 TB platters, in a four-platter configuration; making a 5 TB (5 platter) disk already theoretically feasible. That means 6 TB is the next frontier for magnetic in the consumer range. The Deskstar comes in at $0.09 / GB, while the lowest WD is the 2 TB, at $0.06 / GB.

Meanwhile, very few 2.5″ SSD drives are above 512 GB. And those that are cost a lot; around $2 / GB. Only specialist SSD offerings are above 1 TB, like the OCZ Velodrive 1200GB PCI-E card. However, now we’re talking 3300 Euros (USD 4187), or $3.5 / GB. Compared to the $0.06, that’s a 58:1 ratio.

In other words: SSD still has quite some way to go before it catches up in price and size.

Memory and Storage Prices Decreasing with Time

Comments Off

John C. McCallum has collected a lot of data points for prices on both memory, magnetic disks, and flash, and made the beautiful graph below. It is interesting, since this type of graph is rather rare. He is also plotting the flip-side of Moore’s law; CPU performance, but that’s more common information.

Notice how both graphs are on logarithmic scales. It is interesting to see that the prices of (small) disk drives (in $/MB) has shown a consistent trend for the last 30 years. The very last data point shows a small increase due to the Thailand flood, but still of little significance when put into longer perspective. The DIMM and other memory prices are a bit more varied over the years, but again the decreasing price trend is very consistent, with a rather straight line going back to the very beginning, about 55 years ago.

He seems to update regularly, so be sure to check back on his page. (I hope the direct image link is not a problem).

Comments Off